‘MBA At 16’ by Subroto Bagchi - Review
So an hour or so ago, I finished ‘MBA At 16’, by Subroto Bagchi. I must confess I did not purchase the book, but was given/gifted the book by someone close to the author, and obviously me. Yes, so, I must admit I was a little baffled when I got the book(not a huge fan of non-fiction) and obviously, the purple cover kinda screams right at you. Not to mention the B-school esque logo which has the title. I’d say it’ll draw the crowds pretty effortlessly. Put in a Golden Retriever and voila, they sell like hot cakes.
Anyway, I sat down to read the book after dinner, and was slightly disappointed with the size. True, it is aimed at the teens, but a book the size of a Hardy Boys novel isn’t cool anymore. All the same, I spent a couple of hours reading every word, not just perusing. And I was done. Just like that.
And I will admit, it’s a great book. A great business book. Unfortunately, it is not for the young adults that Mr.Bagchi envisioned. I am a 20 year old MBA aspirant and found the book to be extremely informative, including the tidbits about each businessperson’s inspiration. Also, I must add, I understood majority of the book, which is quite an achievement, considering the not-so-simple terminology used. True, there is a genuine attempt to explain each of those terminologies to the young reader, but alas, that is all it is. The attempt fails, and I must say by quite a margin. Note that it is not because the book is horrible; quite the opposite actually. It is too good to be titled ‘MBA at 16’.
Allow me to elaborate. Each of the topics discussed, from micro finance to venture capitalism are right out of Mr.Bagchi’s mouth. Yes, a 16 year old may be well informed on a few of the topics, but the buck stops there. I’m sorry Mr.Bagchi, but your attempt at creating a young adult business book would’ve paid off if you had redefined the term “young adult”. Instead, the thirty one students that Mr.Bagchi has worked with are 16 year olds whose parents are in the industry or associated with the industry. Also, there is no doubt that these 31 are intellectuals and were “handpicked” by their respective heads of school on that very basis. Precisely where it goes slightly wrong.
Two points of order here. Firstly, these 31, though intellectually capable of having insightful and very productive discussions on the business world, are too small a sample space. For all you might know, there might be one single person with a business acumen on par with or possibly greater than these 31 who was not picked. Secondly, no 16 year old today speaks of the current rate of the dollar or the Eurozone crisis. All they speak of is the next graduation party they’re attending and what country they intend to visit in the summer.
If the very same book had been aimed at an audience of 18-20 year olds, I assure you, it would have been a bigger success. I am still grateful that I had the opportunity to read the book. As a book, it is no doubt exceptional. As a young MBA book, it fails. Unless the idea was to reduce the age bar for college aspirants, in which case FIITJEE is way ahead of you.
Feedback is welcome.
Cheers.

